I take the Maybelline Colour Tattoo in On & On Bronze over my eyelid and under my eyes too, using my finger to warm the product up and blend it. Sometimes I do just leave it at that, but recently I've been reaching for Mac's Eyeshadow in Woodwinked to go on top. They are both very similar in colour, but Woodwinked packs a little more punch than On & On Bronze by itself. What is also great about Woodwinked is that when blended out with a fluffy brush, the colour changes a little. So, it looks as if you've gone to the effort to use a separate eyeshadow in your crease! I then finish off the look with an inner corner and brow bone highlight, and a touch of black eyeshadow along the upper lash line to make it look fuller - occasionally winged liner if I'm feeling up to it.
Do you have any suggestions for bronze eye products? I'd like to experiment with some more!